Do I Need a Smart TV or a Streaming Device?

Introduction: The Streaming Choice Many Households Face

Streaming has completely transformed how we watch television. Cable subscriptions are dropping rapidly as people embrace Netflix, Hulu, Disney+, and dozens of other on-demand platforms. But when it comes to actually streaming shows and movies, one common question arises:

Do you need a smart TV, or should you buy a dedicated streaming device?

At first glance, the two options seem similar—they both give you access to streaming apps and services. But the details matter. In this guide, we’ll explore smart TV vs streaming device: which is better, weighing cost, performance, ease of use, and long-term value. By the end, you’ll know exactly which option fits your household best.

Understanding the Basics

Before diving into comparisons, let’s clarify what each option actually is.

What Is a Smart TV?

A smart TV is a television with built-in internet connectivity and streaming apps. Instead of needing extra hardware, you can access Netflix, YouTube, or Hulu directly from the TV’s menu.

Features of a Smart TV:

  • Built-in streaming apps.

  • Internet connectivity (Wi-Fi or Ethernet).

  • App stores for additional downloads.

  • Voice control on many newer models.

  • Integration with smart home systems.

What Is a Streaming Device?

A streaming device is an external piece of hardware that plugs into your TV (via HDMI) and provides access to streaming apps. Popular options include Roku, Amazon Fire TV Stick, Apple TV, and Google Chromecast.

Features of Streaming Devices:

  • Dedicated operating system optimized for streaming.

  • Frequent updates and app compatibility.

  • Portable—can be moved between TVs.

  • Typically cheaper than upgrading to a new smart TV.

Smart TV vs Streaming Device: Which Is Better?

Let’s break down the comparison by category.

1. Cost and Affordability

Smart TVs:

  • Smart features come included with the TV purchase.

  • Price depends heavily on screen size, resolution, and brand.

  • Replacing a smart TV when outdated is costly.

Streaming Devices:

  • Prices range from $30 to $200 depending on brand and features.

  • Affordable way to upgrade an older, non-smart TV.

  • Easy to replace if technology becomes outdated.

✅ Winner: Streaming devices—much cheaper and more flexible in terms of upgrades.

Another thing to consider is when you use a combination of a streaming device and TV, it allows each to do what they do best. The streaming device takes up the control and management of streaming and lets the TV become a pass through device. It will actuall extend the life of your TV because the streaming device is the engine. 

2. Performance and Speed

Smart TVs:

  • Performance varies by manufacturer.

  • Budget models may have sluggish interfaces.

  • Limited processor power compared to dedicated devices.

Streaming Devices:

  • Typically faster navigation and smoother app performance.

  • Regular firmware updates to keep apps running smoothly.

  • Optimized solely for streaming, reducing lag.

✅ Winner: Streaming devices—generally faster and more responsive.

3. App Availability and Compatibility

Smart TVs:

  • Most include major apps like Netflix, Hulu, Disney+, and Prime Video.

  • Some brands (especially older models) lack certain services.

  • App updates may stop after a few years.

Streaming Devices:

  • Consistently updated app stores with nearly every service available.

  • Frequent updates ensure new apps appear quickly.

  • Stronger support for niche apps (sports, international channels, etc.).

✅ Winner: Streaming devices—better app selection and long-term support.

4. Ease of Use

Smart TVs:

  • One remote for everything—no extra hardware needed.

  • Simpler setup for non-technical users.

  • Menu systems differ greatly by brand, sometimes confusing.

Streaming Devices:

  • Easy setup—plug into HDMI, connect to Wi-Fi, and start streaming.

  • Consistent user interfaces across brands.

  • May require switching TV input (extra step for some users).

✅ Winner: Tie—smart TVs are simpler out of the box, but streaming devices often have cleaner interfaces.

5. Updates and Longevity

Smart TVs:

  • Software support usually lasts 3–5 years.

  • After updates stop, apps may crash or disappear.

  • TV hardware (the screen) outlasts the “smart” features.

Streaming Devices:

  • Frequent updates ensure long life.

  • Easy to replace at low cost when outdated.

  • Better long-term adaptability.

✅ Winner: Streaming devices—more reliable over time.

6. Portability and Flexibility

Smart TVs:

  • Fixed in one location.

  • Cannot easily transfer smart features to another TV.

Streaming Devices:

  • Small and portable—move between TVs or even travel with them.

  • Perfect for households with multiple TVs.

✅ Winner: Streaming devices—highly portable.

7. Integration with Other Devices

Smart TVs:

  • Integrate well with voice assistants like Alexa or Google Assistant.

  • Some models support screen mirroring or casting from phones.

  • Works best within the same brand ecosystem.

Streaming Devices:

  • Strong integration with mobile devices.

  • Features like AirPlay, Chromecast, or Alexa voice control extend usability.

  • Often cross-compatible with multiple ecosystems.

✅ Winner: Streaming devices—generally more flexible for cross-platform use.

Situations Where a Smart TV Makes Sense

Despite streaming devices having more advantages, smart TVs still fit certain situations:

  • Minimalist Setup: One remote, no clutter, simple to use.

  • Occasional Streamers: If you only use Netflix or Prime Video casually, a smart TV may be enough.

  • New TV Purchase: If you’re already buying a new TV, built-in smart features are convenient.

  • Tech-Averse Users: People who prefer fewer devices and cables.

Situations Where a Streaming Device Is the Better Choice

For many households, a streaming device is the smarter long-term option:

  • Upgrading an Older TV: Breathe new life into a non-smart or outdated smart TV.

  • Frequent Streamers: Faster performance and broader app support.

  • Budget-Conscious Buyers: Much cheaper than replacing a whole TV.

  • Travelers or Multi-TV Homes: Move the device wherever it’s needed.

  • Future-Proofing: Easier to replace or upgrade when new tech arrives.

Streaming Devices vs Smart TVs: Real-World Examples

Example 1: The Family Living Room

  • Scenario: Family with a large smart TV that came with built-in apps.

  • Reality: After three years, the TV’s apps became outdated and sluggish.

  • Solution: They bought a $50 Roku streaming stick, instantly improving speed and access to apps.

Example 2: The Apartment Renter

  • Scenario: Renter with a standard HDTV, no smart features.

  • Reality: Instead of replacing the TV, they bought a $40 Fire Stick.

  • Result: Affordable upgrade with all the latest streaming platforms.

Example 3: The Traveler

  • Scenario: Frequent traveler who stays in hotels with basic TVs.

  • Reality: Carries a portable streaming device to plug into hotel TVs via HDMI.

  • Result: Consistent access to their favorite apps and accounts anywhere.

Common Misconceptions

  • “Smart TVs never need upgrades.” False—apps and operating systems eventually stop updating.

  • “Streaming devices only work with smart TVs.” False—any TV with an HDMI port can use one.

  • “Smart TVs are always better quality.” False—the “smart” features don’t affect screen quality. The picture depends on the display technology (LED, OLED, QLED), not the smart system.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use both a smart TV and a streaming device?

Yes. You can connect a streaming device to a smart TV if its built-in apps are slow or outdated.

Do I need the internet to use a smart TV or streaming device?

Yes, both require an internet connection (Wi-Fi or Ethernet) for streaming.

Which lasts longer: smart TVs or streaming devices?

TV screens typically last longer, but streaming features age quickly. Devices are easier to replace.

Are there hidden costs with streaming devices?

No. Once purchased, the only costs are the subscriptions you choose.

Final Verdict: Smart TV vs Streaming Device — Which Is Better?

When comparing smart TV vs streaming device: which is better, streaming devices often come out ahead. They’re:

  • More affordable.

  • Faster and smoother.

  • Easier to upgrade.

  • Portable and flexible.

Smart TVs still make sense if you want a simple, all-in-one solution, especially if you’re already buying a new TV. But for most users—especially those who value speed, app availability, and future-proofing—a streaming device is the smarter choice.

📌 Key Takeaway: If you want long-term flexibility and performance, choose a streaming device. If you want simplicity with no extra hardware, a smart TV may suffice.

No matter which one you choose. you should try to use a hard wire (ethernet) to connect it to either your streaming device or your TV if it supports it. It will provide all the necessary peformance without any concern for buffering. Please see our article on building a home network.     Setting up a home network

43 inch Smart TV with built-in Streaming

55 inch Smart TV with built-in Streaming

Roku Streaming Hub

Apple TV